. 1
( 2 .)



>>

CYET
˜AMOPOXEHH˜I˜˜
7fl
Bau p a c q e ˜ ˜ b l i -
CqeT
3 a 6 n o ˜ ˜ p oC T ˜ - .
˜a˜
PaHMSIMM P ˜ ˜ O T H M K O E
HanOrOBblX M ˜ c n e K q ˜ f i
TaKOe M O X B T CnyqMTbCSI
HOH e OTqa-
C KaXAblM.
M ˜ a f i ˜ e c BblXOA BCC
b,
M H e OAMh.
p a B H 0 eCTb.
n n a ˜ o ˜ e X O˜˜ a ˜ ˜
p F˜ C-
TBeHHaSI X M 3 H b @ M P M ˜ I
M O X e T BHe3allHO A a T b
-
KpeH. ˜ P M W I H H e -
˜
oxMaaHHan ˜ ˜ O K M ˜ O B K ˜
OT
˜BHKOBCKMX
CqCTOB.
T ˜ K HenPMSITHOCTM H e

Ao-
3aCTpaXOBaH HMKTO.
CTaTOqHO JlMUlb H e 3 a n J l a -
TMTb BOBPeMSI K ˜ K O ˜ - T O
H a n o r MJlM O n O 3 A a T b CO
c˜arlei˜anoro˜oi˜e-
Knapaqm. VI B c e - H a -
JlOrOBMKM MMeIOT n p a B O
˜ O M O X ˜˜ p y r 06 a H K i O K a X p C R nOfl B a W M M KOHTpOneM, MX TYT Xe
T
OCTaHOBMTb O n e p a U M M
˜H a n o o T n p a e u T b n o c T a e u n K y . I4 T o r A a - no-
B n e p M O A ˜ ˜ O K M ˜ O BC K eM O B 6 a ˜
qT
no c r e T a M n p o s M H M B l u e - Kcra˜n, @HC n n a H n p y e T y n a H o e M T b
panOK.
˜ ˜ o B M H M B W ˜ ˜ CM p ˜ b HOBble C.leT-3
@ FI l BaM
rocsi n p e A n p M f l T M f l . 3 ˜ o eflMHylo KOMnbtoTepHyto CMcTeMy, no K O T O P O ˜ ˜
H e OTKpOeT. T a K 0 B b l T ˜ ˜ ˜ O B ˜ H V I R
CTaTbM
3HaqMT, qTO PaCXOAOBaTb 6 . 3 ˜ ˜ 1 4Y A Y T C O O HanOrOBMKaM, '-IT0 Bbl
˜ ˜˜˜T˜
Ho
76 H a n o r o s o r o KoneKca. noqeMy 6b1 He
OTKpblnM H O B ˜CWT. T y ˜ x n03neKTpOHHblM
e
nexalqme I˜
CBOM K p o B t i b I e , O ˜ ˜ ˜ B ˜ C T M C P˜ C q e T H b l M CqeTOM B
HOBblM a
K a H a n a M CBR3M MHCneKTOpbl BblWntOT ˜ ˜ H K Y
TO
A p y r O M 6aHKe? BO3MOXHO. B e n b 3TOT
H a O n a n b H b l X CLleTaX,
o 6 n o ˜ ˜ p o M ˜ ˜ o r o reTa.
HMKaKMX CnpaBOK M3 H ˜ J ˜ o ˜ o MHC-˜ ˜ y e e a o M n e H M e e3e c
6a˜K Bo
@ M p ˜ H e CMOXeT.
a T ˜ O ˜ ˜ T M BCe 3C0K O n X H O ˜ P O H ˜ O ˜
˜ ˜ T AM TM
no˜pe6ye˜.3HaTb e M y 0 B a U M X
A
neKuMM H e
˜ ˜ O T ˜ -npoaon-
Ho P TO Gem. O ˜ H ˜ m eO a H m ˜ a n o r o e o i
Kn
B OQMH
npo6ne˜ax e 3 a r e ˜ .
˜
M nOCTaBwMKM c n y m 6 b 1 H e scerna cosnanaia c ee B O ˜ M O X -
XaeTCSI. B TeqeHMe nRTM ˜ ˜nOCJle TOrO, KaK y
ei
˜ HOCTFIMM, M TO " c ˜ e ˜ n o ea w ˜ a n ˜ n o"K a
XOTSIT nonyran nono- t t ) ˜ p ˜ bnOFIBMTCR H O B ˜ C'ieT, 6 a 0 6 ˜ 1˜3 a
˜ H e
l I˜
TaK M OCTaeTCR H a 6 y ˜ a r e .
˜ 0 0 6 ˜ 06˜ b M 3TOM B ee H a n o r o e y t o MHCneK-
XeHHble MM "A˜H˜XKM".
K ˜ BMQMTe, WaHC paCCqMTaTbCR C KOH-
K
UMD, n o n y w ˜ e e A o M n e H M e , ˜ M H O B H M K M
y
C˜opee c e r o , B a w M npo-
B TpareHTaMM y t t ) M p ˜ b leCTb. O A H ˜ KOH CO-
O
OHM Xe HanpaBFIT !A B
MepJIMTb H e CTaHYT. TYT
6 n e ˜ bcl ˜ a n o r o ˜MX i
o nonei
n p o s o w a e T c R o n p e ˜ e n e ˜ ˜ o i pvlclta.
6 a pewewe o 3 a ˜ o p o 3 y xee H o B o r o
˜˜
TOT ˜
Mano BOnHOBaTb. B e n b HeBO3MOXHO TOqHO CnpOrH03HpOBaTb,
y
HO H
C.leTa. e 6 0 n b ˜ 0 ˜ pe30K BpeMeHM
OT
HaCKOnbKO p a C ˜ 0 p 0 n ˜ b l 6 y & ˜ 6 a ˜ T a K,X e
a˜ M
t t ) M p ˜ b l6 y ˜ e L/1 er0 CneAyeT
˜. MCnOnb30BaTb
T a K r(T0 IlpMAeTCSI MC-
nanoroeafi MHcneKumfi. M O X ˜ T
nony-
poAnaR
no MaKCMMyMy.
K a T b cnoc06b1,KOTOPble
'4MTbCR. qTO AeHbrM-TO H a C'ieT nPMAYT, a BOT
CHa'iana HYXHO, q ˜ 0 6 b KTO-TO6blCTpeHb-
l
n03BOnSIT PaCCqMTaTbCSI C Y ˜ T M e ycnetOT.
H
nepewcnmn A e H b r M H a H O B ˜ cIq˜ T @MP-
e
KO
HMMM B CPOK. P a 3 y ˜ e e ˜ c B 1 ,M o x e T e ˜ ˜ C K O H W H O
˜˜I
Mbl. TO M O X ˜ T ˜ MnMTB ˜ U QOnXHMK, HAM
a
˜I
6 a M˜ ˜
˜ P O C ˜ T ˜M3 R a ˜ K a
C6 B OTKpblBaTb B
3 a m ˜ o n a e e u . ˜ TOnbKO 3aBeTHble CpeACTBa
K K
no aoroeopy. Bo-BTOP˜IX,n p e , g n p n R T M e y B a U l e r O KOHTpareHTa ee HeT,
M eCnM TO 3TOT
K a W O M H O B b l e C'ieTa B H a A e X A e PeluMTb
n p o 6 n e ˜ y K O ˜ H ' ˜ ˜ C T B O M ' HO O T K P b l T M e M T p e T b e n M U 0 A O n X H b l CBR3blBaTb T e M n M n y T b PaC'ieTOB W R BaC 3aKpblT.
" '.
- He M H b l e B 3 a M M H b l e 0 6 ˜ 3 a ˜ e n b ˜ ˜ B aT. O P ˜ I ˜
KO Ho M annapa-ra
B n p M HanMrMM K a c c o e o r o
˜ ˜ H K O B C K OC'˜ O
ieTa nRTMMMHyTHOe
y npo6ne-
H y x ˜ o @ O P M M T ˜n o r o B o p , KOHe'4HOM C'ieTe f l O n X H b l 6 b l ˜ b O r a W e H b l .
n nOCTaBu(MKa M O r v B03HMKHYTb
Aeno. O co6pa˜b
M ˜ I . TO n p o m o f i ˜ e ecnm @ ˜ p B ˜ n a H a
˜,
M 3 a B e p M T b ˜ e 0 6 ˜ 0 f l M ˜ b l e ˜ O K Y M e ...T b l˜
HT K ECnM A e H b r M n e p e ' i M C n e H b l C PaC'ieTHOrO ox
c'ieTa B a w e r o A o n x H m a , B c e ˜ T Mc n o B M R
y npO.L@BUy COnMnHyKl CyMMY. B o - n e p B b l x , B
'iTO BCe 3 T 0 M O X e T HeCKOnbKO 3aTflHYTbCR.
K TOMY me 3TOT cnoc06 H e O%Hb y ˜ 0 6 e ˜ BblllOnHRIOTCR. ˜ O ˜ T O M Y H C b l B b l V I r p a T b
Ula B a l u e h KaCCe TaKMX A e H e r H a B e p H R K a HeT.
neno e c n .
cyae6˜oe Benb
flnR KpYnHblX f l p e ˜ n p M f l ˜ M f KOTOPble pa6o- n M M M T OCTaTKa HanM'iHOCTM B KaCCe
i,
T a m c COTHRMM n a p T H e p o B B ˜auoI;I n e u l K e eqe
c flOKa HMKTO H e OTMeHRn. ˜ H ˜ ' - I M T .
OnRTb
B o n p o c b l c HMMM RBHO H e yperynkipyewb. E c n ˜ O T ˜ M B ˜ 3 aM l 0 ˜ ˜
˜ hC ˜ H a n o n p M s n e K a T b 3 a ˜ ˜ o a a MnM a a n e h c -
e˜3
˜ e 6 ˜ ˜ (eawero A O ˜ X H M K ˜ ) .
opa
- 3aKnlo'iMTb C apyrofi
Eue OAMH
B b l H e XOTMTe PMCKOBaTb, eCTb BO3MOXHOCTb TBoeaTb
nYTb
npaeaa, B c x e h n e c n e 6 ˜ ˜ o M o ˜ T ˜ p M ˜ KKT
u aoroeop 3 a h ˜ a B H e M T a K x e
nOCTynMTb no-,L(pyrOMy. opra˜˜3a ˜eh .
yme n o n x H a n sawa Q w p ˜ annoc KO B c e M y
.
HYXHO IlpeAYCMOTpeTb, q T 0 3aMMOnaBeU
- fle6˜1˜0pbl
Apy3bFl s b l n e 3 e s e 3 , ˜ e c y q ˜nf n M m pame-roeH a n M r -
˜ i
flepe.lMCnReT AeHbrM H e Ha B a U p a c ' i e ˜ ˜ b l f i
H b l M M M e w y O p n M U a M M - 6 0 ˜ b l c R ' i py6neA.
a npyrofi Q n p ˜ eK O T O P Y ˜B ˜ TI a M
ECJlll y BaC eCTb AOnXHMKM, IlOnpOCMTe MX creT, (
M o x ˜ o KOHWHO, f l o n p 0 6 0 B a ˜ b 6 0 h ˜ M T 0
,
y ˜ a x e ˜ e ) C O ˜ ˜ H K TO n e H TOT B a p M a H T
O.
paCclMTaTbCh C BaMM, MMHYR p a c l e ˜ ˜ b l f i a H ya 0 3
C'ieT.
cny'iae g e 6 ˜ ˜ o op m e H
B orpaHMretiMe, p a 3 6 n e W e n K y H a HecKonbKo
TOM An 3 a n n a ˜ ˜ ˜ m R M a n b l X npe/JnpMR˜Mfi.
b B e ˜ K flOMOll(M
b
T o ˜ ˜ K o ,c o x a n e ˜ ˜ 3 T,0
o
ne6n˜opoe M XOTR
6naro AOrOBOpOB. K He
H a n p R M y l o B a W e M y KpeflMTOPY. HM M npM6erHpb cnoxHee.
B c e r a a BO˜MOXHO.
r p a m a H c K o e , HM H a n o r o B o e 3 a ˜ o ˜ o n a ˜ e n b c - 6 b 1 n P O C T O M 3 - 3 a OTCYTCTBMR T a K O B b l X B
TBO TaKMeTpaH3MTHble paC'ieTbl H e3anpeUaeT. ˜ a ˜ ˜ MOMeHT.
blfi
mex, K O N ˜ smom cnoco6
HaC y JAR
R)
0
3
˜
0
r$
l B b l n O n X H b l BCerOnHWb HanpaBMTb B 3 ˜ 0 f CMTYaUMM n p a B O H a Bbl'ieT
i
H nodxodum, npednasaeu cnedy-
e
HO 3 a e C b M O X e T B 0 3 H M K H p b
6
CBOeMy A O n X H M K y nMCbMO. HCM YKaXMTe B a C OCTaeTCR.
loquIY1.
peKBM3MTbl K p e A M T O p a M HanMLuMTe, '4TO ne- y x e ˜ a 6 c l e w a ˜ e M OCKOMMHY npo6ne˜a.
Bc
a eMy. H ˜ ˜ o ˜ MHCneKUMR OTKaXeTCR 3a'ieCTb
oB˜R
H b r M H Y X H O nepe'iMUlMTb H e BaM,

CTapbll fl06pbli BeKCenb
kl HAC, n o K a B ˜HI e s e p ˜ e ˜ e 3 a B ˜ .˜ M M e H H o
Aa
B C e 6 b 1 XOpOUlO, TOnbKO B 3TOM ee b
nM'iH0 OnnaTMT HAC,
HAC, B 3TOT M O M e H T Q M P M ˜
Cflyqae n O A Y A a p O M OKaXeTCR B X O ˜ ˜ H O ˜ ˜ B b l M O X e T e BblnMCaTb n e p e B o n ˜ 0 f B e K -
i
KaK T o r 0 T p e 6 y e T nYHKT 2 CTaTbM 171 H a n O r O -
cenb H a CYMMY, KOTOPYO B ˜ 3I a a o n x a n ˜ .
K O T O P ˜ B˜ ˜ KIa K 6 b 1 3 a n n a ˜n˜ C T˜ B U M K y .
I on a

A saw p , o n x H n K TOT B e K c e n b n o A n M w e T
( ( B b ˜ q e ˜ a n n e x a T C Y M M ˜H a n o r a ,
I
no ˜ BOrO KOAeKCa. H ˜ ˜ O M H M M ,
'iTOTaKaR n03MUMR
npenbRsneHHble HanoronnaTenbqMKy n BblCKa3aHa, B LlaCTHOCTM, B n M C b M e MMH@MHB ˜ K u ˜ ˜ T Y ˜ T˜) .C a M b l M O H n O A T B e P A M T
T M
(
y n n a r e H H b l e MM n p M n p ˜ o 6 p e T o e a - ˜ ˜ OT 1 M a p T a 2004 r. NO 04-03-11/28.
PO
˜e˜ c B o e cornawe ero o n n a T M T b . nocne 3 ˜ o r o
-
poe (pa6o˜, y˜nyr))), rOBOpMTCR B CTaTbe M ˜ o m Q l r l p ˜ b CnOPWnM C'iMHOBHMKaMM
e B ˜ co CBOMM n o C T a B q M K o M n o , q n M c b l e a e T e
l I
no TO MY noeo˜y. p m r e ˜ n o n H e y c n e w H o .
n
171 H a n o r o s o r o K o a e K c a P O . 3 ˜ a c l u ˜ ,
HAC, aKT ˜ ˜ M ˜ M K M - n e p e e Ka e n R A co cso-
Bn cw
B
B 6 0 n b W c l ˜ c T B ec n y q a e e C Y A ˜pas pew an^
I
0 n n a ˜ e ˜ ˜ b p e T b M M M JlMUaMM, K Bbl'ieTY
Tl f i M M n O n X H M K O M B a M H a A O n O A n M C a T b aKT 0

. 1
( 2 .)



>>